smalishah84
The Tiger King
who do you guys think is the greater cricketer and reasons?
Would a team of XI Marshalls beat a team of XI Vivs?Had to vote for Marshall because he was the best quick of all time, whereas Richards, as good as he may have been, wasn't the best batsman (even if you exclude Bradman).
Would be close I reckon. I'd pick the Marshalls in Tests but the Vivs in ODIs.Would a team of XI Marshalls beat a team of XI Vivs?
Viv, by a whisker for me. Great batsman, imposing personality and a more than useful captain later on to. Was instrumental in helping West Indies win the 1975 and 1979 WCs. Marshall was a better bowler than Viv was a batsman, but since the question is of 'cricketer', I'm adding in a few other parts as well.
Can't believe they had so many ATGs in one side.
WhaaaaaaaaaaaaaayNot much to choose between them in Tests but Viv was a vastly better ODI player so Viv.
Dunno about that. He might've been.whereas Richards, as good as he may have been, wasn't the best batsman (even if you exclude Bradman).
What does that mean?Whaaaaaaaaaaaaaay
You can mount a reasonable argument that McGrath was the equal to or superior of Marshall. I'd still run with Mako, but it's at least arguable.Had to vote for Marshall because he was the best quick of all time, whereas Richards, as good as he may have been, wasn't the best batsman (even if you exclude Bradman).
Judging them as bowlers only in all conditions they're about on par I reckon. Agree with that for sure.You can mount a reasonable argument that McGrath was the equal to or superior of Marshall. I'd still run with Mako, but it's at least arguable.
Sure, I'd almost buy that re: McGrath. But there must be at least 20 batsman who you could make a reasonable argument for being equal or better than Viv.You can mount a reasonable argument that McGrath was the equal to or superior of Marshall. I'd still run with Mako, but it's at least arguable.
People bringing ODI's into discussion when the OP specifically not mentioning that they shouldWhat does that mean?